Sofema Online (SOL) Presents an overview of the BASA structure from the perspective of Brazil – ANAC
Introduction
From the perspective of ANAC (Agência Nacional de Aviação Civil), the BASA is a risk-management instrument codified in international law. It enables the Risk-Based Validation (RBV) of aeronautical products and the mutual recognition of surveillance systems. The following structure outlines how ANAC operationalizes this agreement, moving from the treaty level to the working procedures used by certification engineers and airworthiness inspectors.
Tier 1: The Executive Agreement (The Treaty)
Legal Basis: This is the diplomatic treaty signed between the Government of Brazil and the partner state (e.g., the U.S., Canada or EU member states).
ANAC's Function: It provides the statutory authority for ANAC to share proprietary data (IP) and accident investigation information without violating Brazilian sovereignty or confidentiality laws.
Tier 2: The Annexes (Scope of Competence)
The Executive Agreement is segmented into functional domains.
- Annex 1 (Airworthiness): Covers Design, Production, and Airworthiness Certification (RBAC 21).
- Annex 2 (Maintenance): Covers Repair Stations and Maintenance Organizations (RBAC 145).
- Other Annexes: Flight Simulation Training Devices (FSTD), Environmental Certification, etc.
Tier 3: The Implementation Procedures (The "Working Documents")
These documents define the Level of Involvement (LoI) and the specific validation paths. Note the terminology difference depending on the partner:
- With FAA (USA): IPA (Implementation Procedures for Airworthiness).
- With EASA (Europe): TIP (Technical Implementation Procedures).
- For Maintenance (Both): MAG (Maintenance Annex Guidance).
- With TCCA (Canada):
Airworthiness: IPA (Implementation Procedures for Airworthiness). (It focuses heavily on the "Validation Improvement Roadmap" (VIR) to streamline the certification of the Embraer E2 in Canada and the Airbus A220 in Brazil.)
Maintenance: TA-M (Technical Arrangement – Maintenance).
Airworthiness & Design: The "TIP/IPA" Mechanism
In this domain, ANAC operates primarily as the State of Design (SoD) for Embraer and the State of Registry (SoR) for imported aircraft.
The Core Principle: Maximizing Reliance
The modern BASA (especially Revision 6 of the FAA-ANAC IPA and Revision 5 of the EASA-ANAC TIP) has moved away from "shadow certification" to Risk-Based Validation (RBV).
- Certifying Authority (CA): The authority of the State of Design (e.g., ANAC for an Embraer E2).
- Validating Authority (VA): The importing authority (e.g., FAA).
The Validation Process (RBAC 21.29)
When Embraer seeks an FAA Type Certificate (TC) for a new jet, the BASA dictates that the FAA (as VA) does not re-certify the plane. Instead, they define a Level of Involvement (LoI) based on three criteria:
- New Technology: Is there something novel (e.g., a new fly-by-wire law)?
- Novel Usage: Is the aircraft being used in a new way?
- Past Performance: Does ANAC have a known competence in this specific area?
Reciprocal Acceptance (The TSO/ETSO Shift)
A critical recent evolution in these agreements is the move from "Validation" to "Acceptance" for lower-risk articles.
- Old Way: A Brazilian manufacturer makes a radio. They need an ANAC TSO and an FAA Letter of Design Approval (LODA).
- New Way (Reciprocal Acceptance): The FAA automatically accepts the ANAC TSO (and vice-versa) without issuing a LODA. The "approval" is recognized directly.
Maintenance: The "MAG" and "TA-M" Mechanisms
For MROs (Maintenance, Repair, and Overhaul), the BASA structure relies on specific implementation documents to facilitate the reciprocal acceptance of maintenance. While the core concept (Reliance + Supplement) is consistent, the execution differs significantly between partners.
The Core Mechanism: The "Supplement" Strategy
For an SME, the critical realization is that ANAC RBAC 145 certification alone is insufficient for international work. The BASA does not declare "RBAC 145 = Part 145." Instead, it bridges the gap via a Maintenance Organization Exposition (MOE) Supplement.
- The Formula: RBAC 145 Approval + Partner-Specific Supplement = Deemed Compliance with Foreign Regulations (14 CFR Part 145, EASA Part-145, or CAR 573).
A. The United States (FAA) – The "MAG"
- Document: Maintenance Annex Guidance (MAG).
- The Release (Dual Release): The FAA is unique in that it requires the Brazilian MRO to issue FAA Form 8130-3. Under the MAG, an ANAC-certified shop is authorized to issue this US legal document. This is often referred to as a "Dual Release" because the block 12 remarks cite both the ANAC and FAA authority.
- Critical "Special Condition" (SSD): Drug & Alcohol (D&A). This is the most frequent stumbling block. Brazilian labor law conflicts with US-style random drug testing. The MAG requires a specific, separate D&A testing program that meets 14 CFR Part 120 standards, which is not required by ANAC.
B. The European Union (EASA) – The "MAG"
- Document: Maintenance Annex Guidance (MAG)
- The Release (Equivalence): Unlike the FAA, EASA does not require the MRO to issue an EASA Form 1. Instead, EASA accepts the Brazilian ANAC Form F-100-01 as equivalent.
- SME Detail: The Form F-100-01 must contain a specific release statement in the "Remarks" block (Block 12) referencing the EASA Part-145 approval number (e.g., "EASA.145.XXXX").
- Critical "Special Condition": SMS & Human Factors. While ANAC has implemented SMS, EASA places heavy emphasis on Human Factors training and specific occurrence reporting channels that align with EU 376/2014
C.Canada (TCCA) – The "TA-M"
- Document: Technical Arrangement – Maintenance (TA-M). Note: The outlier. Do not reference "MAG" for Canada.
- The Release (Equivalence): Similar to EASA, TCCA accepts the ANAC Form F-100-01. The Canadian "TCCA Form One" is not issued by the Brazilian MRO.
- Critical "Special Condition": The TCCA supplement is generally "lighter" than the FAA's. It focuses on ensuring the "Major Repair/Major Alteration" definitions align with Canadian CARs, as the definition of "Major" differs slightly between ANAC and TCCA.
SME Takeaway: Managing the "Delta"
For a Quality Manager at a Brazilian MRO (e.g., TAP M&E or Azul Tec Ops), the BASA is not a "blanket pass." It is a map of Special Conditions.
USA – Compliance Check
- Protocol: Maintenance Annex Guidance (MAG).
- Release: Issue FAA 8130-3.
- The "Gotcha": Verify all personnel are enrolled in a Drug & Alcohol Program (49 CFR Part 40).
Europe – Compliance Check
- Protocol: Maintenance Annex Guidance (MAG).
- Release: Issue ANAC F-100-01.
- The "Gotcha": Confirm Human Factors training and include the Specific Release Statement exactly as required.
Canada – Compliance Check
- Protocol: Technical Arrangement on Maintenance (TA-M).
- Release: Issue ANAC F-100-01.
- The "Gotcha": Audit Major Repair Definitions and ensure strict CAR 573 Alignment.
Summary of Competencies
For ANAC, the BASA is a recognition of its status in the "Big Four" (FAA, EASA, TCCA, ANAC). It validates that Brazil’s RBAC (Regulamento Brasileiro de Aviação Civil) system produces safety outcomes statistically equivalent to 14 CFR (US) or CS (Europe).
Role: Checking Homework
- Simple Explanation: One authority verifies the work already completed by another.
- SME Explanation (ANAC Context): The interaction and division of responsibility between the Validating Authority (VA) and the Certifying Authority (CA).
Process: Re-doing Tests
- Simple Explanation: Determining the extent of redundant testing or review required for a foreign design.
- SME Explanation (ANAC Context): Utilizing Risk-Based Validation (RBV) through a clearly defined Level of Involvement (LoI).
Output: Permission to Sell
- Simple Explanation: Obtaining the necessary approvals to market or operate aeronautical products in a new jurisdiction.
- SME Explanation (ANAC Context): Achieving Type Certificate Validation or ensuring the Reciprocal Acceptance of TSO/Parts.
Document: The Agreement
- Simple Explanation: The formal legal framework that governs how different countries work together.
- SME Explanation (ANAC Context): Following the IPA (Implementation Procedures for Airworthiness) with the FAA, the TIP (Technical Implementation Procedures) with EASA, or the MAG (Maintenance Annex Guidance)
Next Steps
Sofema Aviation Services (SAS) and Sofema Online (SOL) Provide Classroom, Webinar & Online training please see the websites email t[email protected]