With a career in commercial aviation spanning over five decades, beginning in 1971, Steve Bentley FRAeS has spent more than 30 years hands-on within the safety and compliance arenas. Today, as the CEO of Sofema Aviation Services and Sofema Aviation, he leads global efforts to shift the industry from a culture of basic regulatory box-ticking to true operational excellence.
As the aviation industry grapples with increasing operational complexity, systemic gaps in how organizations identify, report, and manage non-compliances persist. In this discussion, we challenge the conventional reliance on regulatory oversight, break down the anatomy of a failed root cause analysis, and re-examine where ultimate operational accountability sits.
Interviewer: Steve, let’s start with a foundational misconception that seems to plague many aviation organizations. When a Competent Authority (CA) inspector completes an audit and finds zero or minimal findings, there’s often a sigh of relief and a feeling that "everything is perfect." Why is that a dangerous assumption?
Steve Bentley: It’s dangerous because it mistakes a lack of findings for total organizational health. A Competent Authority audit is a sampling exercise; it is absolutely not a "stock-taking" of every process, part, or person in your facility. CA inspectors look at a slice of the pie on any given day. They look at what they want to look at, within a limited timeframe.
When an organization interprets a quiet CA audit as a stamp of approval for their entire ecosystem, they are living under a compliance illusion. The CA is there to provide regulatory oversight, not to act as your quality control or to guarantee your operational excellence.
Interviewer: To that point, you’ve often argued that if a CA inspector does find a major non-compliance, something has already gone fundamentally wrong internally long before they walked through the door.
Steve Bentley: Exactly. Think about the layers of defense. If an external regulator spots a systematic issue, it means it was missed by the people executing the work, missed by the Business Area Owner, and missed by the internal Compliance Monitoring Department.
If the CA finds a problem, it is rarely just a localized error. It is almost always an indicator of systemic disconnects and potential disconnects across the organizational hierarchy. It means your internal mirrors are warped. A healthy organization should always find its own trash and clean it up before an outsider has to point to it.
Interviewer: When internal or external findings are raised, the immediate regulatory requirement is to perform a Root Cause Analysis (RCA). Yet, we repeatedly see poor performance because organizations fail to get to the bottom of the issue. Why do we keep getting RCA wrong?
Steve Bentley: Because human nature seeks a simple, linear narrative. People want a smoking gun - a single neck to choke or a single broken widget to replace. But in aviation, it is seldom a single root cause. It’s almost always a combination of latent systemic weaknesses that aligned perfectly at a specific moment.
Furthermore, organizations routinely ignore or under-report contributing factors. This creates a massive systemic blind spot. While a surface incident is typically what gets fixed, the contributing factors are left unaddressed. A contributing factor didn't cause the event on its own, but it created the environment that allowed the root causes to manifest. If you only fix what you think is the primary root cause and ignore the context-fatigue, vague documentation, high turnover, poor tooling-the exact same failure will morph and happen somewhere else.
Interviewer: On the topic of getting RCA wrong, there is another massive trap companies fall into: stopping the investigation the moment they hit a human error. We often see audit responses that list the root cause simply as "operator error" or "human factors," followed by a corrective action like "retrained the employee." What is fundamentally flawed about that approach?
Steve Bentley: That is perhaps the most pervasive and damaging misconception in aviation safety management today. Human factors can never be a root cause. Ever.
When an engineer misses a step, or a pilot misinterprets a data point, that human error is the symptom of a deeper systemic failure, not the origin of it. It is the starting point of a real investigation, not the finish line.
Human error is an output, not an input. If you stop at "the mechanic made a mistake," you haven't done a Root Cause Analysis; you’ve just assigned blame.
In a properly executed RCA, you must always drill deeper. You have to ask why the human factors came into play. Why did the smart, well-trained, well-intentioned professional make that choice at that exact micro-second?
If you ask "why" five times, you don't find a lazy employee. You find ambiguous procedures, commercial pressure that rushed the job, poorly designed tooling, unlit work areas, or fatigue driven by systemic scheduling issues. If an organization labels "human factors" as the root cause, they are essentially saying, "Our system is perfect, but our humans are broken." That is a mathematical impossibility and a total cop-out.
Interviewer: It feels like there is a stark contrast between this superficial approach to auditing and what happens when things go catastrophically wrong.
Steve Bentley: The difference is night and day. The group that does not leave a single stone unturned is the Accident Investigation Boards (AIB). They don't sample, and they certainly don't stop at "pilot error", they perform a forensic, exhaustive autopsy of the entire system, the culture, and the history of the organization. But by then, it’s typically too late. The damage is done, lives may have been lost, and the brand is ruined. Proactive compliance is about turning over those stones ourselves before an accident board has to do it for us.
Interviewer: Let’s talk about ownership. Under EASA and other major frameworks, we have designated Post Holders and Business Area Owners. Where does their fundamental responsibility lie when poor performance creeps in?
Steve Bentley: The fundamental responsibility for compliance and safety lies squarely with the Business Area Owners and Post Holders - not with the Compliance Manager, and certainly not with the regulator.
In a mature aviation system, the roles should be perfectly distinct. The Post Holder or Area Owner owns the risk, manages the performance, and ensures processes are robust and actively followed. The Compliance Department acts strictly as an independent internal auditor and advisor to verify that the system functions as promised. Finally, the Competent Authority simply verifies via high-level sampling that this entire internal loop is closed and functional.
Too often, Business Area Owners treat compliance as the Compliance Department’s problem. They think that if Compliance didn't flag it, they are fine. That is a complete inversion of how a performance-based system works. If your department is underperforming or non-compliant, it is a direct failure of management control within that business area.
Interviewer: To wrap things up, Steve, what is the ultimate takeaway for aviation executives trying to break this cycle of superficial compliance?
Steve Bentley: We must move past the culture of box-ticking and passive oversight. Leadership needs to realize that compliance isn't a goal to achieve just to pass an annual audit; it is the absolute baseline of operational survival.
Invest heavily in your internal compliance monitoring, empower your auditors to look deeply into systemic health rather than just checking paperwork, and hold your business area owners accountable for understanding why their systems break. Don't wait for an accident board to show you where the stones were left unturned.
Sofema Aviation Services (SAS) and Sofema Aviation (SA) Provide Classroom, Webinar & Online training. Explore 525+ aviation courses at Sofema, or contact [email protected] for support.
Found this useful?
Share it with your network on LinkedIn.